Julian Speroni best keeper in the Football league

Crystal Palace goalkeeper Julian Speroni performed heroics to single-handedly earn a vital point for the Eagles against Barnsley at the weekend.

The Argentinean won huge praise for his performance at Oakwell on Saturday from Palace manager Paul Hart and in my opinion he is the finest stopper in the Football League and up there with the best of them in the Premier League.

Speroni joined the Eagles prior to Palace’s Premier League season in 2004/05 under Ian Dowie but after a series of blunders as number 1 was dropped and replaced by Gabor Kiraly.

But since the Hungarian’s departure from Selhurst Park Speroni has stepped up and become easily one of Palace’s best and most consistent players in recent years. He has won back-to-back player of the year awards to firmly cement himself in the hearts of Palace fans.

While many players’ form dips and troughs under different managers Speroni has continued to be at the top of his game under four different managers.

There is no question that the 31-year-old will provide a crucial role in the upcoming weeks as the Eagles battle for survival. I feel that Speroni is the player that will make the difference between Palace beating the drop come May.

Palace’s goal difference of minus one may be sniffed at by teams occupying the top spots in the league such as Newcastle who boast plus 40. But I find Speroni’s record impressive because of the lack of defensive quality he has in front of him.

The Eagles have suffered since Paddy McCarthy’s shoulder injury and Jose Fonte left for Southampton in January with Matt Lawrence or Clint Hill, both preferred full backs, stepping in alongside Claude Davies.

Both Hill and Lawrence are defenders that I would consider a risk and wouldn’t put too much faith in if they were defending in front of me, especially compared to Newcastle’s solid centre half partnership of Fabricio Coloccini and Stephen Taylor.

However it is no coincidence that Palace’s goal difference looks distinct fully healthier than the teams in the bottom half bar Watford who have England under 21 international keeper Scott Loach.

Loach was reportedly chased by Tottenham Hotspur boss Harry Redknapp in January and I feel that Speroni is on par if not better than the Watford number one.

While the Crystal Palace January transfer window itinerary focused around the departure of Victor Moses there were many Palace fans hoping that the race to sign the Nigerian born winger would over shadow the signings of other players.

And I feel that no other member of the squad was more important to hold onto than Speroni, who left Dundee to join the Eagles when the Scottish side were suffering financially. The attention on Moses proved a blessing in disguise without a club coming within a sniff Speroni.

Neil Warnock joins QPR from Crystal Palace

Warnock's way out to be respected not criticised

Neil Warnock‘s departure as Crystal Palace manager on Monday night confirmed many Eagles fans fears as the Yorkshire man joined Queens Park Rangers.

The switch to the west London rivals ended speculation over Warnock’s future who has set his sights at being a Premier League manager once again.

The 61-year-old has claimed to only have a couple years of management left in him and sees QPR as being a club more capable of giving him his dream of becoming a top-flight manager again rather than Palace.

And I have to admit I agree with him. They are clearly more financially stable and appear to have a better set up in terms of looking ahead to the future while the Eagles are currently concentrating on finding a buyer, a new manager and escaping relegation.

While QPR are just one place above Palace many will question Warnock’s decision but I feel he has made the right one – for Neil Warnock.

Is it a selfish decision, well yes, but it had to be. His position as manager of Crystal Palace could not be guaranteed if a new buyer was found and the temptation of managing at Loftus Road was simply too good to resist.

I doubt that many fans will blame Warnock’s choice especially after it was made clear that he wasn’t just going to walk out on the Selhurst Park club. Warnock was keen to make sure Palace received compensation for his move, he said: “”There is no way I am going to walk out. If they can agree compensation then that's different.”

After agreeing a compensation deal the following breaking news was inevitable. As an Eagles fan who Warnock took some time to win round I am now convinced he is a descent manager and one that is sure to become QPR’s longest serving manager in recent seasons.

But I fear some fans will, wrongly, envy Warnock and blame him for walking out when the club needs him the most. But with an online poll on a dedicated fans website voting 45 per cent in favour of not blaming him while just over 10 per cent will boo him when he returns to south east London as QPR boss on the 10th April as they ‘passionately dislike him’.

There is no doubt we need a manager like Neil Warnock the most now as we battle for survival but his exit is not the same as Steve Bruce or Ian Dowie who left under bad terms with the Palace faithful.

I feel Warnock’s move is more similar to that of former Palace striker Andy Johnson who simply had to leave for the benefit of his own career. But only time will truly tell if his choice is the right one.

Warnock set to leave Crystal Palace for rivals QPR

Warnock the right man, but not the only man

Growing speculation over Crystal Palace manager Neil Warnock moving to Queens Park Rangers will worry many Palace fans who believe he is the right man to lift them out of their current turmoil.

While the Eagles are enjoying an exciting and money rewarding cup run their league form appears to be struggling as they dropped into the bottom three after a one nil home defeat to Coventry managed by former Palace player Chris Coleman.

Warnock has admitted that he is concerned over his future with Palace who are set to receive £1.5 million in compensation if the switch goes ahead.

However despite the compensation, which will be a welcomed acquisition for the Selhurst Park outfit, many will fear for the club’s future if Warnock leaves for their West London rivals.

There is no doubt that Warnock is the right man for the job with his passion and desire to win that shines through in Palace’s performances, but he is not the only man.

Ian Wright, who scored twice for Crystal Palace in their 3-3 FA Cup final against Manchester United in 1990, recently claimed that Warnock was not the right man for the job insisting: “They need a young manager with new ideas,” hinting at a possible move for himself.

“If I can be part of that, then it's something I'd have to consider,” he added. While Wright may not be the ideal candidate if a candidate at all to replace Warnock there are many other former Palace aces that could take and crucially want to take the job.

One ideal candidate and only person I feel that can replace Warnock is ex-Palace manager Steve Coppell. The former Reading boss has a soft spot for the south London club, as does the Palace faithful for him, after having four spells as manager.

In many cases the ideal scenario is often the most unlikely but it may not seem too distant especially after the departure of Simon Jordan who Coppell famously had numerous ‘personality clashes’ with.

When questioned by ITV’s Steve Rider before Palace’s dramatic home game with Villa Coppell didn’t deny that he might possibly, one day, play a part in their future.

Ian Wright also confirmed that he thought Coppell was thinking of getting involved again along with former owner Ron Noades.

But Coppell may not be the only man eager to take the job on with Gareth Southgate left jobless after being sacked as the Middlesbrough manager in October 2009.

The former Palace player will be eager to prove himself after a poor record at the Riverside but may pose something of a risk if appointed as Warnock’s successor. Southgate is a man that to me comes across as too nice in an end of season battle that will be fought hard to the very end.

With every vacant managers job there is always one rumoured possibility that shocks fans and could it be too daft to suggest a return for Steve Kember. The Palace legend performed a miracle by rescuing the Eagles from relegation in 2001 but left on bad terms under Jordan who promised Kember a ‘job for life’.

The manager’s job at Selhurst Park is not a very appealing one for experienced managers at the top of the English game and relying on the love of the club may prove crucial in attracting a manager that can lift us out of relegation and look ahead to a bright future.

If Warnock is be confirmed as QPR boss later this week – leaving many Palace fans, including me, devastated - there will be no better way to leave than to mastermind a shock win over Aston Villa in the fifth round replay at Villa Park on Wednesday.

FA Cup provides sanctitude for cash-strapped clubs

Year-on-year the FA Cup provides us with great memories and occasions but this year’s competition has one more reason to be loved in a valentines weekend fifth round that was crucial for financially stricken clubs.

England’s most lucrative cup competition is renowned for ‘David v Goliath’ clashes and money-spinning ties between non-league sides and league opponents with the financial reward a great incentive for teams. This year’s cup, which so far is remembered for Northwich Victoria’s famous victory over Charlton Athletic in the first round and Leeds United’s win against Premier League Champions Manchester United in the third round, involves no non-league sides anymore but still has teams chomping at the bit to progress to the next round for the financial reward.

Cash-strapped clubs Portsmouth, Crystal Palace, Cardiff City and Notts County were all in action in this weekend’s fifth round. Cardiff and Notts County suffered heavy defeats away at Premier League opposition but still earned financial reward through game receipts. However the big earners, for a change, in this weekend’s action were heavy debt rollers Portsmouth, who beat Southampton, and Crystal Palace, who drew with Carling Cup finalists Aston Villa.

Ahead of Portsmouth’s 17-mile short trip to south-coast rivals Southampton on Saturday there was speculation in the morning papers that it could well have been their last game. The 2008 Cup winners have until Friday to prove they can service debts of up to £60million.

Saturday’s 4-1 win over the Saints did not only provide Pompey fans with derby day bragging rights but was a great lift to the fight against the financial problems facing the club. The club are set to receive around £500,000 including TV revenue, prize money and gate receipts. Had they lost that game it could have been the final nail in the coffin but the FA Cup, which for some clubs is becoming less of a concern and overshadowed by league ambitions, could turn the fortunes of Portsmouth football club around.

Albeit half a million pounds is a long way off their totalling debt - an FA Cup run could be the answer to many Pompey’s fans prayers with a quarter-final home draw against Birmingham City in a round that see’s two of the competitions favourites meet each other. Chelsea face Manchester City if they can overcome Stoke City at the Britannia in a reply of the 1-1 draw at Eastlands on Saturday and many Portsmouth fans may be beginning to believe they can achieve something in this year’s Cup.

Am I suggesting they can win it, well not entirely but, with manager Avram Grant firmly behind the side and showing passion previously never shown during his tenure at Chelsea - a cup run with progression through to the semi-finals worth £360,000 it could prove crucial to Pompey’s survival.

Meanwhile Crystal Palace, who were on the verge of producing one of shocks of the fifth round against Aston Villa before a late headed equaliser by Stiliyan Petrov, achieved what administrator Brendan Guilfoyle would describe as the perfect result.

However manager Neil Warnock may disagree after the Palace manager was disgusted with the award of the corner which led to Petrov’s header. The chance to go back up to the Midlands in the FA Cup, this time to face Aston Villa as opposed to previous cup opponents Wolves, will land more finances for the club in a game that is surely destined to be screened live after today’s epic encounter – generating further television money.

Palace are set to cash in on a 20,000 attendance that enjoyed a game played in great spirit, bar an Ashley Young dive early on, and what appeared a terrific atmosphere at Selhurst Park. With television rights worth £247,000 for the game and a replay, if won, set to earn £180,000 the FA Cup will provide the south London club with much needed cash.

And if Palace do perform the unlikely and beat Villa in ten days time Warnock may not feel too heavily aggrieved with Kevin Friend’s decision to award a corner after the ball clearly rebounded behind off Nathan Delfouneso's head. The reward for beating Villa will be a trip to either Reading or West Brom in the quarter final and is it too ridiculous to suggest Crystal Palace in the semi-finals – which between now and then would see them earn £560,000 just in prize money.

The Eagles are soaring since they were plunged into administration less than three weeks ago and the news which devastated everyone involved with the club has seemed to galvanise them.
But the impressive way Palace have managed themselves, or should I say been managed by Neil Warnock, has attracted interest elsewhere and reports before kick-off that Queens Park Rangers have taken a keen interest in Warnock will worry many fans who believe he is key to escaping the financial woe currently surrounding the club.

'Season Over'

Well it’s all over for another year according to manager Neil Warnock who has blamed the disappointing form since the turn of the year on injuries to key players such as Paddy McCarthy and Claude Davis. After returning from a group of fixtures that saw the Eagles pick up just four points from four games and has seen them drift from possible play off contenders to mid table mediocrity. They sit eleven points adrift of the play offs and are ten points in danger of sinking into the drop zone.

The post Christmas form that in the past has seen palace creep into the play offs at just the right time is now just a fond memory. The Burnley side that fought back to beat a palace side that led two nil reminded me too much of an Ian Dowie team I once knew. Burnley certainly showed signs of ‘bounce back ability’ while Palace fell victim to a dubious penalty decision, which of course left Warnock fuming, and crumbled. The few hundred fans who travelled that day did not only have to suffer a four two drumming but watched on as palace players marched off the pitch without a single salute, except midfielders Nick Carle and Neil Danns, towards the contingent of red and blue support. The normally appreciative Neil Warnock wasn’t even acknowledging the fans, this after, he had of course berated the referee and official for awarding the penalty.

After this game I, like Neil Warnock does now, thought the season was over but the impressive away win at Swansea the following Saturday had me rethinking. Until I was brought back down to earth by the defeat to relegation threatened Barnsley. Now I accepted the season was over.

The risk of being dragged into a relegation battle while at this stage is not a big issue may still happen. Tough fixtures against teams in the top half of the table as well as games against teams fighting it out at the bottom, combined with the poor form of late, could see that issue turn big, very big. After a much needed international break palace will return to face QPR, Coventry and Cardiff in eight days before travelling down south to St Mary’s to play a Southampton side who have lost just once in seven games. This time next month things could be looking much worse for Palace fans and missing out on the play offs may not seem so bad after all.

So thoughts turn to rebuilding for next year and with Warnock admitting that there will be little money to spend next season the aim for the summer must be on keeping hold of the young players. Players such as Victor Moses and Nathanial Clyne, who has emerged this season as another product of the youth academy, could be tempted by Premiership football next year. Hopefully they will learn from previous youngsters that have left Selhurst Park in search of top-flight football, the likes of John Bostock who has played a handful of games for Spurs and Wayne Routledge who again left for Spurs but after failing to impress has returned back to the Championship.

As for signings, a goal scorer is a must but with Chairman Simon Jordan wanting to sell it looks like they will sign no-one capable of taking Palace back to the Premiership. Warnock has said that ‘he is hopeful of making a number of Bosman free transfer signings of the summer’, some ambition. The 2009 summer transfer window will probably consist of the ‘one in one out’ system that palace have been using so far in 2009, where by a player has had to leave before another can be bought in, Darren Fletcher and Danny Butterfield made way for Claude Davis and Anthony Stokes. So unless the club finds a buyer before the end of the summer then Palace could be staring at the same situation this time next year.


o